Alternatives to a Raise, and What Each Really Costs

By Marco Colasacco, Co-Founder and CEO. Last updated:

The main alternatives to a raise are a one-time bonus, a stipend, a lifestyle spending account (LSA), a discount program and an essentials cashback benefit like Amplify. With Amplify, giving an employee $2,000 more costs your business $1,600 instead of $2,000 as a raise: a raise that costs 20% less. On the employee side, our illustration shows a $1,200 raise and an Amplify membership both costing you $1,292, while your employee keeps $888 from the raise against $1,188 from Amplify: 34% more, on the assumptions shown under the table.

A $1,200 raise next to an Amplify membership, for illustration

For illustration only. This is Amplify's worked example, not a quote, an offer or tax advice. The assumptions are stated under the table.

A $1,200 raise next to an Amplify membership, for illustration
$1,200 raiseAmplify membership
Employer direct cost$1,200$1,200
Employer payroll tax (7.65%)$92$92
Total employer cost$1,292$1,292
Value delivered to the employee$1,200$1,500
Employee tax (illustrated at a 26% combined rate)$312$312
What the employee keeps$888$1,188

Assumptions behind the example

  • Annual amount. Illustrated at an annual amount of $1,200 per enrolled employee, with up to $1,500 in cash back.
  • Full eligible spending. The employee uses their full eligible spending. To earn $1,500 at 10%, the employee makes $15,000 of qualifying purchases in the year.
  • Tax rate. A 26% combined employee tax rate. This is illustrative and varies from person to person.
  • Payroll tax. The employer's 7.65% payroll tax is applied to the $1,200 in both columns.

How does Amplify cost 20% less than a raise?

To give an employee $2,000 more as a raise, your business pays $2,000 plus payroll taxes. Through Amplify it pays $1,600 a year for that employee and Amplify adds $400 of its own. The employee can earn up to $2,000 back as 10% cash back on essentials they already buy, so the same payout costs your business 20% less.

You can also spend the full $2,000, and your employee can then earn up to $2,500, with Amplify funding the extra $500. The 20% and the 34% on this page are two views of the same math: 20% is what your business saves on the same payout, and 34% is how much more your employee keeps after tax in the $1,200 example.

A $2,000 raise next to Amplify, for illustration
Your business paysYour employee can earn
Raise$2,000 plus payroll taxes$2,000
Amplify, same payout$1,600Up to $2,000
Amplify, full budget$2,000Up to $2,500

What are the alternatives to a raise?

Five come up most often: a bonus, a stipend, an LSA, a discount program and essentials cashback. They differ in how they are taxed and in whether the money reaches the bills your people pay every month.

A one-time bonus. It is generally taxable pay that lands once, and next year starts from the same base. That helps with a bad month. It does little for the grocery bill that comes back every week.

A stipend or allowance. It is taxed like pay, because a benefit is taxable unless a specific exclusion applies (IRS Publication 15-B). It also arrives as general money, so it can be gone on other things before the electric bill is due. Our guide to helping employees with grocery costs puts stipends next to four other approaches.

A lifestyle spending account (LSA). It is generally taxable too, and you choose the menu it covers, so it often pays for gym fees or wellness items while rent and groceries sit outside it (Forma, Benepass, Compt). Our LSA vs cashback card comparison goes through the two side by side.

A discount program. It takes something off the price at partner retailers. It does not put money back in anyone’s account when they spend.

An essentials cashback benefit. This is what Amplify does: 10% back on household bills, from groceries and rent to the phone and the electric. The rest of this page shows what that is worth next to a raise at the same cost to you.

What does a raise really cost?

A raise costs more than the number on the offer letter. The IRS sets the Social Security tax at 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, and Medicare at 1.45% for each (IRS Topic no. 751). Your share is 7.65%. On a $1,200 raise that is about $92, so the raise really costs you $1,292.

It also stays. Next year’s pay starts from the higher figure, and so does every year after that. You are not making a one-time decision. You are adding a standing cost.

Why does your employee keep more with Amplify?

You spend the same $1,292 either way, so the difference is what reaches your employee and how it is taxed. A raise is generally taxed in full as pay. At the illustrated 26% rate that takes $312, and your employee keeps $888.

Amplify’s Terms of Service set out the tax treatment. Cash back you earn up to the amount of the annual payment is reported as imputed income, in the same way a lifestyle spending account is. Cash back above that amount is not taxable. This describes how the program is reported. It is not tax advice, your own circumstances may differ, and you should speak to your own adviser.

In the illustration, tax applies to $1,200 of the $1,500 in cash back, which is the same $312. The other $300 reaches your employee untaxed, so they keep $1,188.

How is the 34% worked out?

$1,188 divided by $888 is 1.34. Your employee keeps 34% more after tax, and your cost has not moved from $1,292.

The illustration assumes your employee uses the full eligible spend. An employee who spends less on qualifying purchases earns less cash back, and the gap over a raise narrows with it.

The ratio is the same at any annual amount you choose, because the maximum cash back is proportional to what you pay (1.25 times in this illustration). This page shows one amount. Cash back is earned only on qualifying purchases at approved merchants in the nine essential categories.

Where does the extra value come from?

It comes from where the money is spent. Your employee loads their own money onto an Amplify account and spends it with an Amplify card, physical or digital, on groceries, housing, gas and electric, water and sewer, internet, mobile phone, fuel, childcare and auto repair. Each qualifying purchase earns 10% back into the same account. A raise is spent on the same bills, but nothing comes back.

The limits are part of the design. The card works anywhere it is accepted, but the 10% is earned only where the category is covered and the merchant is approved. The maximum cash back is proportionate to the annual amount the employer pays, which is why the illustration says “up to” $1,500. Those rules are what keep the 10% on rent, food and fuel.

On your side, the cost is set by you and does not compound. You pay the annual amount you choose for each enrolled employee, with no capital, no credit risk and nothing for staff who stay out. You decide who is eligible and whether to continue, so it never creeps into next year’s base the way a raise does.

On your employee’s side, there is no monthly fee, no annual fee, no interest, no minimum balance and no credit check. Cash back posts after the purchase settles, normally within a few business days, with nothing to claim. Amplify is currently enrolling employers in New Jersey. See how the per-employee fee works on the employer page.

Frequently asked questions

Where does the 34% come from?

From Amplify’s illustration. A $1,200 raise and an Amplify membership each cost you $1,292 in total. Your employee keeps $888 from the raise and $1,188 from the membership, and $1,188 divided by $888 is 1.34. It rests on the assumptions under the table, including full eligible spending.

What does an employer pay for Amplify?

The employer chooses the annual amount it pays for each employee who enrolls. The maximum cash back is proportional to what the employer pays, 1.25 times in this illustration, which uses $1,200. The illustration is not a quote.

Does the employee have to spend a certain amount?

The illustration assumes full eligible spending. To earn $1,500 at 10%, that is $15,000 of qualifying purchases in the year, at approved merchants in the nine essential categories. Spending less earns less cash back.

Is Amplify part of an employee’s pay?

No. It is an employer-sponsored benefit. Per the Terms of Service, Amplify is not part of compensation and is not a promise of continued employment. The money in the account is spent with the card; it is never paid out as cash.

Is Amplify available now?

Amplify is currently enrolling employers in New Jersey, and it is offered through employers. No launch date has been announced. If you want it for your team, use the form on this page and we will get in touch.

How much less does Amplify cost than a raise?

To give an employee $2,000 more, a raise costs your business $2,000 plus payroll taxes, while Amplify costs $1,600 a year and adds $400 of its own. That is 20% less for the same payout, or up to $2,500 for your employee if you spend the full $2,000.

Amplify is currently enrolling employers in New Jersey.

Want it for your team? Tell us a little about your business and we will be in touch.

Talk to us

Get in touch

Talk to us.

Pre-enrolling today.

Amplify is partnering with employers in New Jersey that want to be early adopters. There are only 500 employee slots available, so reach out today!

By sending this you agree we can contact you about Amplify. We use what you send here to reply to you, and nothing else.